September 2014 Beauty Box 5 Review

Disclosure: If you make a purchase through the links posted below, I may receive a small compensation. Read the full disclosure.
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links.
Beauty Box 5
Cost: $12/month.
Ships To: The lower 48 United States and Canada via the Postal Service.
Coupon Code: N/A
September 2014 Beauty Box 5
September 2014 Beauty Box 5

Today was another pretty good mail day here which included the arrival of my September 2014 Beauty Box 5.

Beauty Box 5 is a monthly subscription service that delivers a sample box of all things beauty. Each box contains 4 – 5 samples of a variety of makeup, skin care, fragrances and everything in between!  Boxes are $12/month if you do a month-to-month subscription, however, I subscribed a while back when they had a crazy deal that brought the cost of an annual subscription down to $6.58/month.

September 2014 Beauty Box 5
The Box

Beauty Box 5 ships via USPS.  My box took a total of five days to get to me (in MI) from TX which I didn’t think was too bad.

September 2014 Beauty Box 5
First Look

First look was so-so.  Nothing looked overly amazing, but it didn’t look awful either.

September 2014 Beauty Box 5
The Information Card

The September 2014 Beauty Box 5 included the following fall favorites to help keep you toeing the line between taking care of yourself and embracing new trends:

~Nicka K New York Eyelight Crayon (Violet) ($4.49): This is fun!  It’s easy to apply and gives you a smooth shimmery eye color.  It’s super easy to blend too.

September 2014 Beauty Box 5
Nicka K New York Eyelight Crayon

~Natural Style by FUBU Deep Conditioner & Co-Wash ($0.83): This isn’t the same FUBU as the clothing line is it?  I am guessing no, but I guess it could be?  Anyway, the conditioner is suppose to work as a co-wash for curly haired-girls and as a deep conditioner for all other hair types.

September 2014 Beauty Box 5
Natural Style by FUBU Deep Conditioner & Co-Wash

~Sally Hansen Toe Spacers ($1.99): Meh.  I am not too excited by toe spacers.  It’ll be a cute little add-on in to all the nail polishes I am sending in my cousin’s care package though.

September 2014 Beauty Box 5
Sally Hansen Toe Spacers

~My Beauty Spot Nail Polish ($4.17): I’ve never heard of this brand before, but the color is really nice.  I *might* even be able to get away with using just one coat too, which I never can do.  It has a weird smell though.  It’s stronger than most other polishes I’ve tried.  Not too sure why that is, but you’ll want to open your windows when you put this on.

My Beauty Box Nail Polish
My Beauty Spot Nail Polish

~Chrislie Formulations 3-in-1 Eye Bright ($13.60): I have yet to find a product that makes my tired eyes feel as good as just closing them and putting a cooling eye mask on, but that’s not always possible I guess.  This did feel good when I put it on, but my container seemed like it was almost empty?  Did anyone else notice this?

September 2014 Beauty Box 5
Chrislie Formulations 3-in-1 Eye Bright

All totaled I came up with a value of $23.09 for the September 2014 Beauty Box 5.  I’m just kind of meh on this box.  Certainly not my favorite ever, but I still think it was worth the ~$7 I spent on it.

Do you subscribe to Beauty Box 5?  What’d you get in your box this month?  I know there are usually some variations, so I would love to hear what you got!  If you are interested in subscribing or want to check out more, click here.  

Screen Shot 2014-01-11 at 10.35.35 PM

Spread the love

Jennifer

Jennifer is the author and founder of Subscription Box Ramblings. She first discovered subscription boxes in 2012 and has been addicted since. Current favorites include CAUSEBOX, Boxycharm and Beachly!

This Post Has 5 Comments

  1. Cheryl

    I got the same items as you, but my nail polish is in a mauve color and my eyeshadow is a khaki green. Nice fall colors. I was wondering about the FUBU too!

    1. sun

      Oh I got the mauve polish too-it was my first box. The color looks awful on me kind of looks like I’m sick. I thought several layers would help, but that made it worse. I have a medium beige skin tone and that might be why.

  2. lynn m.

    The polish probably isn’t a 5 free like julep and other higher end polishes that all of us are spoiled by. Which is why it is super smelly and no so great for you 🙁

    1. Jennifer

      That probably is it!!

  3. Lexis Luther

    I got this egyptian magic all purpose skin cream ??? I’d rather have had the lash em 🙁 the fubu thing, lmao! ! I was a little impressed at how my hair felt afterwards bit the products I get from all my other subscription makes this company look … well, I’m grateful any who 🙂

Leave a Reply