Subscribe for notification

Julep NY Mystery Box Review

Disclosure: If you make a purchase through the links posted below, I may receive a small compensation. Read the full disclosure.
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links.
Julep
Cost: Monthly Subscription: $24.99/month (My Maven) / $39.99 (Maven Luxe). LA vs. NY Mystery Box: $24.99 (one-time purchase).
Ships To: United States, United States Minor Outlying Islands, and Canada.
Coupon Code: New customers can use one of the following coupon codes: “”FALLGIRL” to get a free Ombre Welcome Box, “HAPPY” to get a free September Birthstone Welcome Box, “GLOW” to get a free Korean Skincare Welcome Box, “WOW” to get a free Lipstick Welcome Box, or “GIMME” to get the White Hot Neutrals Welcome BoxYou can also opt for a free Custom Welcome Box.
Julep NY Mystery Box Review
Julep NY Mystery Box

My Julep NY vs. LA Mystery Box (I opted for the NY) has arrived!  I ordered it last week and also opted for an add-on with my box.  Since I ordered a Fall Mystery Add-On,  I really have no idea what items were part of the MysteryAdd-On and what were part of the Mystery Box, so am going to review them all as one.  I really need to stop ordering Mystery add-ons because it drives me a little crazy that I can’t separate them.

If you aren’t familiar, Julep is a monthly nail polish subscription service.  They offer a “My Maven” box for $24.99/month which contains $40+ worth of product and polish or “Maven Luxe” for $39.99/month which contains $60+ of prestige products.  Both boxes are fully customizable and you have the option to switch between tiers.  Every once in a while (probably every month or so) they offer Mystery Boxes which are available for purchase by subscribers and non-subscribers alike.

The Box

Julep ships via FedEx Smart Post (starts out with FedEx and is delivered by USPS) and took just a short time to arrive.

First Look

This box was packed!!  Mystery Boxes don’t include information cards, but here is what my NY Mystery Box (plus Fall Mystery Add-On) included:

~Julep Plie Wand ($20 / $25): Getting one of these in my Mystery Box made me realize that I don’t use my own plie (which I used to think was “pile”) wand nearly enough.  Like I used it at first and then kind of forgot about it.  I did think it helped make polishing easier, but not easy enough for me to remember to use it on a consistent basis I guess?  If you have one of these I am curious to hear if you still use it? I am going to give this to my Julep obsessed friend and see what she thinks.

Julep Plie Wand

~Julep Rock Star Hand Creme ($16 / $20): I love Julep’s hand cream! Like the package says, it’s a hit!  I use it on my hands and elbows and have always been happy with it.  It’s thick, but it rubs in nicely and doesn’t leave your hands all greasy.

Julep Rock Star Hand Creme

~Julep Nail File & Buffer Block (~$3): Not overly exciting, but useful.  I always need more nail files and I do like buffing my nails with buffing blocks.

Julep Nail File & Buffer Block

~Julep Oxygen Nail Brightening Treatment ($14.40 / $18): I NEED to start using this. I constantly have polish on my nails but mainly because they have been looking like crap otherwise. And if my polish ends up staining my nails, well, I can’t more polish on there fast enough.  This is supposed to help strengthen nails and brighten them.

Julep Oxygen Nail Brightening Treatment

~Bianca (Bombshell) ($11.20 / $14): Bianca, which was in all LA vs. NY Mystery Boxes, is a textured silver holographic glitter.  I’d need to throw another polish underneath for better coverage, but I think it’s a great silvery glitter.

Bianca (Bombshell)

~Fifi (It Girl) ($10): Fifi is a tea time pink creme. I like this color, but it doesn’t really like me unless I use a bunch of coats of it.  I may have to do a layer of white polish underneath to give me the coverage I want.

Fifi (It Girl)

~Michelle (Boho Glam) ($11.20 / $14): Michelle is a midnight, inky blue crème.  I almost think this one looks a little teal.  In the right light it does that’s for sure.  It’s very fall like which is what I was hoping for from this box.

Michelle (Boho Glam)

~Colton (It Girl) ($11.20 / $14): According to Julep, colton is a black iris creme.  I think it’s more purple than black though.  It’s certainly fall-like and will be on my nails next.

Colton (It Girl)
Swatches

~Julep Travel Caddy: I don’t know that I *need* a travel caddy for my polishes, so I may use this as a large manicure kit.  Just leave a couple polishes and tools in it and grab it when ever the mood strikes.

Julep Travel Caddy
Inside

All totaled I came up with a value of $97 (that’s using discounted Maven pricing) for the Julep NY Mystery Box.  That doesn’t include the value of the Julep Color Caddy because I can’t find a price for that online.  After coupons, I paid $34.98 for the Mystery Box plus my Mystery Add-On set, so it was totally worth it.

Did you order a Julep NY vs. LA Mystery Box?  What’d you think? They are no longer available, but I will for sure post when they release the next Mystery Box.

Spread the love
Jennifer: Jennifer is the author and founder of Subscription Box Ramblings. She first discovered subscription boxes in 2012 and has been addicted since. Current favorites include CAUSEBOX, Boxycharm and Beachly!
Related Post