Fancy Mystery Box Giveaway!!!

Disclosure: If you make a purchase through the links posted below, I may receive a small compensation. Read the full disclosure.
Disclosure: This giveaway is sponsored by Ramblings of a Suburban Mom and is in no way affiliated with, sponsored by or endorsed by any of the brands included. Please read the Official Rules which are located in the Rafflecopter widget under “Terms and Conditions” prior to entry. This post does contain affiliate links.
Fancy Mystery Box
Fancy Mystery Box

I am so sorry for the outage yesterday (although this one was totally NOT my fault) that I wanted to make it up to you, so I thought I’d do a Welcome Back Giveaway!!! This giveaway is for a Large Fancy Mystery Box (you know how I love my Mystery Boxes). Your choice of Men’s or Women’s! If you aren’t sure what to expect, you can check out my reviews here. I’ll order it when the giveaway ends and when the winner selects which one they’d like to receive. If you win, you have to promise to tell me what you receive in the box though!!!

You know the drill, just enter in the Rafflecopter widget below and you will be all set. And, as usual, you get a free entry every day, but you can do all that extra stuff, including sharing and tweeting to gain extra entries! Good luck and welcome back!

a Rafflecopter giveaway

Screen Shot 2014-01-11 at 10.35.35 PM

Spread the love

Jennifer

Jennifer is the author and founder of Subscription Box Ramblings. She first discovered subscription boxes in 2012 and has been addicted since. Current favorites include CAUSEBOX, Boxycharm and Beachly!

This Post Has 264 Comments

  1. sindhu

    The modcloth grab bags were great! I got 4 really nice dresses.

  2. Enrica

    I don’t think I’ve gotten anything ‘stellar’ but I do love when the surprise/mystery boxes are so worth the $$.

  3. jessie m

    The best thing I ever won in a grab bag was a Alex and Ani bracelet or a gift card to Lush.

  4. Jen K

    Books! Honestly I don’t do a lot of subscription boxes. But once I got some Chronicle Counting books and they were awesome.

    Also I come here, look at your reviews and go get some stuff that I have been eyeing. So Thank you!

  5. Shawna

    Best thing I’ve ever gotten in a box? I think I am still waiting for that day to come!

    I’ve loved a few things, though, most recently the Betsey Johnson pj set from Wantable Intimates. I LOVE that subscription!

  6. Steph

    It’s hard to say, I really love scarf from the April PS box but then again the nest candle that I got in my $10 mystery box was pretty amazing too.

  7. Elizabeth

    I have to choose just one item? I think my favorite is the Bodum Bistro Mugs from PopSugar (sent out forever ago). I reach for one all the time, and I was devastated when a roommates broke one of the mugs!

  8. Caroline R.

    Great idea! Your last couple mystery box reviews were awesome with no wall decals in sight 😉

  9. MJ

    My favorite item I’ve received so far is the Malin Goetz face mask from PopSugar! I love it!

  10. Tiffany M

    OH i would so LOVE to win this! I ordered a regular mystery box before they offered sizes and totally got the boring box most people received. Such a drag. Tempted to try again though. Best thing I ever got in a subscription box has to be my Brokedown scarf in a popsugar box. That scarf has gotten the most use out of everything.
    beijos,
    Tiffany

  11. Gina G

    These medium and large mystery boxes look much better than their $10 mystery boxes I bought a few weeks ago. Even though I feel I wasted money on the early ones, I may have to try again…

    1. Gina G

      Oops forgot to answer the question… best thing I ever got in a mystery box was a Oia Jules necklace from JewelMint.

  12. Adrienne W

    The best thing I ever got from a mystery box was a black retro cocktail dress with gold stitching detail. It was worth $150! I paid $10 for it when ModCloth had Stylish Surprise deals.

  13. Andrea S

    Mine would be the muk luk slipper socks from Wantable intimates – they are a little big on me but I love having cozy toes!

  14. Tori

    The best thing I’ve ever gotten from a subscription/sample box was this amazing eye cream. I don’t even remember exactly what it was called, but it left my skin so soft!

  15. Denise

    Too Faced Natural Eyes Palette! from PopSugar =)

  16. Lori

    The best thing I got in a mystery box was a bottle of Julep nail polish (in a Citrus Lane box) It introduced me to the product, which I now love!

  17. Stephanie Forgach

    The best item I ever received from subscription box was Faith Aromatherapy Sugar Scrub. It came in an Ipsy box and I fell in love with it!

  18. Amanda

    Thanks for the giveaway, been wanting to try the fancy mystery box!

  19. Ashley K

    My favorite thing I got in a subscription box was probably sea salt spray! I love it!

  20. Cassidy

    Nail Polish gets me every time

  21. Elizabeth

    I love the Chella highlighter pencil I got in Birchbox a few months ago. It was one of those things I never knew I needed until I had it. Plus, it was full size and worth more than I paid for the box!

  22. Brianna

    I haven’t been subscribing to anything for very long, so that’s kind of tough….

    I’m expecting my first citrus lane box this week, that will probably be my fav. But so far I think I like the Nivea Kiss of Color from the limited edition Birchbox best. It’s kind of boring I know, but I love that stuff! That was a great box for me.

    1. Monica

      Holy cow! That is awesome.

  23. mspotts

    I ordered from the something store, where you pay $10, and they will send you something…and got a Kindle Fire!

    1. Jennifer

      Ohh, that is fabulous!

    2. Crystal Gregg

      Oh, how fun. I just ordered something! Hopefully ill get a good one too 🙂

      1. Jennifer

        Let me know what you get!

        1. Crystal Gregg

          Ugh… An ugly stone bracelet that I could’ve bought for $1.
          I’m giving them one more try though since I love surprises in the mail. Hopefully won’t be wasting another $10 haha

          1. Jennifer

            That’s it??

  24. julie b

    I loved everything in pop sugar winter luxury box. i also love love love last month’s pop sugar scarf.

  25. Diana Kang

    The brokedown ikat scarf in popsugar must have!

  26. Samantha

    I’ve never had a subscription box or anything of the sort

    1. Kathy Heck

      My Favorite (so far!) is from March’s Popsugar Must Have box , my Baublebar elephant ring holder! I have it on the window shelf by the kitchen sink. Always makes me smile when I see it. A bit of brightness before I dig into doing the dishes! 🙂

  27. Andrea

    the best thing i have ever received in a subscription box is the blue and white scarf from popsugar. it goes with everything!

  28. erica

    I loved the custom made for Box of Happies leaf earrings I got this month! I’ve worn them nearly every day since.

  29. Jennifer

    Melie Bianco Mattie Bag!!! It’s absolutely gorgeous and totally something I would buy.

  30. Candy Gibson

    Love this blog! I grew up in MI, so when you post pics or talk about Meijer, I miss it so much!

    1. Jennifer

      Thanks! Where did you grow up?

      1. Candy Gibson

        I grew up in Milford, but my folks moved to Hartland, several years ago, I live in Wichita, but make it to MI a couple of times a year, Oh how I miss Spicers and Highland House!

  31. crazyalisa

    A pair of organic cotton pjs that my LO loves. Cost twice the cost of the box and I would have never spent that kind of money on PJs, but kiddo loves them, so they were an awesome surprise.

  32. Kat E.

    I’ve wanted to order a large box for the past few weeks but haven’t made the plunge.

    1. Kat E.

      But the coolest thing I’ve ever gotten was 100% pure mascara… that stuff is amazing and smells so good!

  33. Julia

    I got the CUTEST shoes in my modcloth surprise, that’s probably my favorite surprise turn out. I also got the cutest dress from modcloth surprise, so I’m really hoping they do another one since it was such a win for me!

  34. Rose D.

    AAHHH!! So many choices! I think two of my all time favorites have been the anniversary circle necklace, and the Kai perfume oil, both from Popsugar.

  35. kathryn

    One of the best things I’ve gotten was from the ModCloth apparel mystery bag! It’s a gorgeous maxi dress. Black and white striped tank top with a slightly gauze dark yellow bottom, cannot believe I only paid $10 for it!

  36. Jenny Whiskey

    The best thing i ever got in a Mystery/grab bag was my Red Jessica simpson coat from ModCloth’s Stylish Surprise. I paid $15, picked my size and got a beautiful red pea coat that fit like a dream! And it retailed for a good $120. WIN!

  37. Jordan

    I love the Nutwhats that I discovered from Treatsie. I always love salty/sweet snacks!

  38. lynn m.

    Suki face scrub or green toys items

  39. Kara

    My favorite items are my golden tote goodies!

  40. Bethany

    Oh gosh. Your giveaways, they are just too awesome!! Favorite thing I’ve ever received in a box would probably be the bullet necklace from SocialBliss.

  41. Jen

    The best thing I have ever gotten in a box was an Alex and Ani bangle bracelet!! WHOOT!!!

  42. Bridget Heiple Reich

    In the most recent People VIP box, I received a brush that’s like the Knot Genie. I know that’s not too exciting, but my daughter loves it and it makes brushing her hair so much easier!! 🙂 I know I’ve gotten other things I really love, but I can’t think of them right now!!

  43. Chelsey

    At this time I would say the best thing from a box was the bare minerals lip gloss I got from ipsy last month my new fav!!!

  44. Jenny

    Oh my this is such a hard one. Lets see I love my brokedown scarf in the fall/winter months. Pretty much all nailpolish is at the top of my list 😉 Introducing me to Warrior Poet shirts with Wittlebee is a highlight too since N loves them so much and he can even hold a conversation with the boutique owner hear about his favorites.LOL I’m pretty sure she keeps ordering them just for him 🙂

  45. Lanie

    I’m pretty new to subscription boxes, but I’m pretty sure my favorite item is arriving any day now in my Brooklyn themed Hazel Lane box.

  46. Mary Ann

    I’m still really new to subscription boxes, and I’ve never tried a Fancy Box, but so far, my favorite item was a Harvey Prince perfume (“Hello”) that came in my first Birchbox!

  47. janelle

    Ooh. I loved modcloths grab bags. I got 2 awesome shirts and a cute dress.

  48. Madelyn

    I think I’d have to say that the best item so far is the Cuyana infinity scarf from Popsugar. I’m in Minnesota, so it got a LOT of use. A lot. In fact I’m wearing it today as there are flurries outside. Sigh. Save me from this weather, please.

  49. Emily K

    I don’t have a huge amount of sub box experience, but I LOVED this stacking toy that bluum sent once in a box!!

  50. Kiersten

    I’m loving that Too Faced Palatte from Popsugar last month. I’ve always wanted to try the brand but couldn’t justify it.

  51. Sher

    My purple yoga pants from Wantable Intimates, definitely!

  52. Brandy Fisk

    Silly but, I got introduced to deep steep lotion stick and I’m always buying it for my sons cheeks.

  53. Rose

    My favorite items have then the Stila palette in the special edition PopSugar box, and the handbag in the last stylebox.

  54. Shannon

    That’s tough. I’ve just found out about the glorious world of subscription boxes! So far my favorite thing is the clutch from the Resort box. But my son loves the stuff he gets in citrus Lane.

  55. Lynsey

    Over the knee brown boots for $10 from ModCloth.

    What outrage?? I miss everything LOL

    1. Jennifer

      Outage? My server was down ALL day yesterday!

      1. Lynsey

        Sorry I obvs don’t know how to read. 🙂

        1. Jennifer

          LOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  56. Hagit

    The best thing I have ever gotten in a box was an new korean cc cream [MEMEBOX]

  57. Lisa

    The best thing was the Tokyo Milk from the PSLE – I love that stuff!

  58. Loren

    Man, idk…Right now I’m obsessed with swapping for more PurLisse SPF 30 moisturizer from a Blush box last year, and also Julep cuticle oil, although I never got that from one of their boxes. I’m impatiently waiting for my Too Faced palette from Popsugar!

  59. Kyra

    The best things i’ve received were last months brokedown ikat scarf and that little ring holder elephant, I use it every night!

  60. Abbi B.

    This month Ipsy introduced me to St.Tropez and I can happily say I will no longer be exposing myself to tanning beds! Its seriously amazing for anyone who is like me and has to have a tan year round!
    Love your giveaways, hopefully this is my lucky one!

  61. Elizabeth

    Everything from Petit Vour has been great. But I’m addicted to the Beurre Body Butter. It smells so good, I want to taste it. I’ve been giving away all my other lotions…going to place an order & get enough to give away. It’s THAT good.

  62. Gillian Lovatt

    I think my favorite thins is the Brokedaw scarf from the PS March box…..have barely taken it off since I got it!

  63. G Kwon

    The best thing = definitely Benefit’s They’re Real! It’s how I came to realize the importance of mascara 🙂

  64. Krista

    I don’t know how I can pick just one thing! I love that I have enough mascara to last me three lifetimes. I also love the Alex and Ani bracelet that came in last month’s Glossybox–I’ve already ordered two more!

  65. Adrienne D.

    An awesome Alex and Ani swan bracelet from Glossybox!

  66. Lauren S

    It’s not super or over the top or anything, but it has been my favorite so therefore it’s the best thing I’ve gotten in a subscription box, the giving keys necklace from FabFitFun! It was really cute and the charity is really great, and following the idea of the necklace, I’ve already passed it along!

  67. Judy

    Scarves, full size facial moisturizers and masks, tech items like portable speakers and phone chargers! 🙂

  68. Staci

    The best thing I’ve received in a box would have to be the tea collection onsie in February’s citrus lane box. Such a cute little baby outfit. Also, I loved a tribal print infinity scarf I got in my stitch fix box last month.

  69. Andrea

    My favorite is definitely some of my Golden Tote items. Probably one of the most recent was the great Porridge shirts they came out with!

  70. Mandy B.

    The April PopSugar Must Have was my first subscription box! I was so excited about everything but my favorite was the eyeshadow palette – such great colors.

  71. Chelsea

    I’ve only gotten 2 subscription boxes so far but I love that I will use everything that comes in them!

  72. Chris

    I received a beautiful scarf in my Popsugar box. It is by far the most used item so far.

  73. Emily

    i think my favorite is the popsugar juice beauty moisturizer. i still use it every day

  74. SMDC

    My Cuyana Turkish Towels-SO SOFT.

  75. Shawn

    My favorite items are always skincare; loving the Jergens body BB body cream from the Target Beauty box right now. So inexpensive but the cream is great.

  76. Gina F.

    I don’t know if there was anything really special I got in a mystery box, but I am always a sucker for makeup!

  77. Megan L.

    This might sound crazy, but the best thing I’ve ever gotten were the headphones in the JLH Fancybox. It’s the only Fancybox I ever got (had a coupon code or something – they’re just so expensive!) but I use the heck out of the headphones. They’re a gorgeous teal color and my son has used them on flights quite often. I didn’t use a single thing from the rest of the box, but those headphones – aweeeesomeee! Worth the price of the box alone.

  78. Mary Beth

    My favorite item was in my first PS box. The wetbrush. I was going through a bad hair faze and it totally fixed my issues. It was a product I would never have tried and it’s what got me hooked on the discovery aspect of sub boxes.

  79. Wanica

    Hi Jenn,
    Your ears should be burning because I totally name dropped you to Fancy :). When I called Fancy about the tour my large mystery box is making on the west coast (I live in Alabama),I told them several comments regarding your review spoke of the exactly the same problem.

    1. Jennifer

      Ha! i didn’t take the boxes on a tour!!!

  80. Shannon

    My favorite thing I have gotten in a sub box is the be a bombshell eye shadow pallette. So pigmented. This is corny but also the ladies of my sub box Facebook group. They are the best for advice. 🙂

  81. Lauren

    My favorite item was the Too Faced eyeshadow pallet from Popsugar!

  82. Andrea

    I’m totally bummed- I have to start limiting my sub boxes because money is tight. My favorite things I’ve received are a reversible tote from Stitch Fix and the Bodum mugs from Popsugar:)

  83. Annie

    It seems like every month Wantable Intimates sends me a new favorite thing I’ve ever gotten! April it was two super soft tank tops that fit perfectly.

  84. Charity

    Those hello kitty ear bud clip things from Qbox. I use them everyday!

  85. kay

    My husband got me blue apron as a valentines day gift, and I think getting groceries and recipes might be my favorite mail ever!

  86. Sophie V

    I am new to the subscription box world but I must say any type of nail polish is always a plus!! Just ordered my first Julep mystery box and am very impatiently awaiting it’s arrival.

  87. Vicky Taft

    So glad it wasn’t my computer having issues, though bummer about the site being down. This is actually the only blog I read on a regular basis.

    The best thing I’ve received in a sub box would be the Cailyn tinted lip balm I just received in April’s Ipsy bag. I got the acid pink color which is super bright pink, sooooo perfect for me. I rocked it last night for work.

    1. Jennifer

      It was such a mess. Bluehost (my server)’s Facebook is a giant disaster of complaints from people! I couldn’t believe it was down so long!!!!!! I tried not to be too annoyed, but I was. LOL.

  88. Beth

    The Molasses Spice cookies from Grey Ghost Bakeries that came in my Love With Food box. My son and I both loved them! Really good flavor and they’re chewy instead of crisp or super soft.

  89. Christine

    I’m new to these boxes – I get Ipsy and Glossy Box and my husband gets Loot Crate. I have purchased 5 of the Fancy Mystery Boxes (before they came in sizes) 2 mens and 3 womens. I now have 2 of the vinyl wall decals.. well 3 of them but 2 are the ‘ones’ everyone got. So with my limited experience I’d say the best thing I’ve gotten so far was from my first Ipsy bag last month – Bare Minerals Moxie lipstick in Get Ready. I tend to favor lip gloss and the color seemed bright for me and perhaps not age appropriate but I quickly fell in love with it and bought the full size one.

  90. Sarah

    It’s kind of boring but my favorite thing was the Vichy Aqualia Thermal Rich Cream that came in my very first Glossybox. I fell in love with that stuff! And subscription boxes… As as aside, I tried to follow you on instagram but it just says “requested”. Not sure what that means since I’m not an Instagram pro but… 🙂

    1. Jennifer

      Oh I think I accepted??

  91. Juli

    I’ve gotten some scarves that I absolutey love.

  92. Kristy

    I can’t even pick one thing!

  93. Stacey

    The wall decals from the small fancy mystery box…

    Just kidding. 😉

    I think my favorite item I’ve gotten is the elephant ring holder from last month’s PSMH box. Its so cute!

    1. Jennifer

      Ha!!

  94. Sara

    I always love the beauty extras in Julep’s boxes – specifically the hand scrub and lip gloss!

  95. LaurenKay

    Brokedown Scarf from the September 2012 Popsugar Must Have Box

  96. Amanda

    I feel like every month is a surprise with sub boxes, I don’t think I can pick just one!

  97. chelsea

    The Fancy Mystery Boxes are my favorite and the best thing I got was the Ellie black bags.

  98. Stacey

    I’m think my favorite thing is on the way! I’m anxiously waiting for this months bag in SocialBliss!!! (I hoping for navy- I have never had a navy purse either!)

  99. melissa m

    Best thing I have ever got was about half of the stuff in the Wantable Intimate Boxes. I have gotten 2 boxes and I LOVE LOVE LOVE several of the items.

  100. Crystal Gregg

    Because I use it every day I’d say from either birchbox or Ipsy the Be A Bombshell eyeliner

  101. Rachel U.

    My favorite was the salt water taffy from the ps resort box!- that stuff is so good don’t you think?

  102. Jill

    My favs have been Erickson Beamson rock bangle or Micheal Stars scarf – both from PS!

  103. Debbie BJ

    I think it would have to be the Stila pallet from pop sugar mh last year. My oldest girl keeps trying to take it and I tell her that it’s mine put it back..lol

  104. Sarah

    I use the Ivory+Mason sunglasses from the FFF box last summer EVERY day!!

  105. Helen

    The best thing I’ve gotten was the truffle-flavored Pipcorn that came in PopSugar. I love anything truffle-flavored so it was such a treat to be introduced to the popcorn.

  106. Jordan M

    Oddly enough, the double ended blue/gold eyeliner from Smashbox that came in the Resort Popsugar box is my favorite. It had already become a staple of mine and it’s not even summer yet when it will be perfect.

  107. Sara W

    Best thing I?ve ever gotten in a box? A target GC for 20$!

  108. Erica

    THIS IS SO HARD TO CHOOSE! I think probably that Brokedown Ikat scarf in PopSugar. But I am currently wearing the gold Gorjana circle necklace from PopSugar and the Dogeared necklace as a bracelet. And I really love my Turkish towel from the Resort Box.

  109. Kristen

    I must say I’m LOVING the two faced pallet I just received from PSMH!!

  110. miranda

    I love the scarf from last month’s PopSugar

  111. Allison

    My favorite sub box thing is that Barr & Co Diffuser from Popsugar a few months ago… mmmmm… 🙂

  112. Rebecca

    I pretty much like all the skin care products I get from Birchbox. I am clueless when it comes to skincare so it is very helpful.

  113. mary m

    I’m not sure what my favorite item would be…We’ve gotten so many fun things from Citrus Lane.

  114. emily o

    loved the cinnamon candy hearts in popsugars February box… I can’t find them anywhere!
    And I loved the towel in the resort box

  115. Esther

    Thank you for doing this!!

  116. jmd

    So far, the best thing I think I have gotten in a mystery or subscription box was the Vasanti Face Wash – I have already ordered full sizes twice!

  117. Patty

    Great giveaway! The best thing I ever got in a mystery box was a beautiful dress from Modcloth in the most perfect shade of dandelion yellow. And not that you asked, but worst thing: “Work Hard Stay Humble”.

    1. Jennifer

      LOL!!!!!!!!!!! I have gotten worse.

  118. Cathy@Five Boys

    I love so much of the stuff I get in my Popsugar boxes, it’s hard to pick one. If I had to though, I love the ikat scarf!

  119. Robyn

    Have never done a mystery box!!!

  120. Elissa

    The best thing I’ve ever gotten was the Bliss Foaming Face wash from the FabFitFun box a while back

  121. Valerie

    The best thing I ever got in a box was the Bare Face Cleansing Oil I received in a Julep mystery box last year. It was an awesome surprise!!!

  122. Jill Banks Geraci

    Favorite thing I think is the Tokyo Milk body cream. I’ve traded for about 3 more jars since receiving it in the PSMH Holiday Box.

  123. cindy

    makeup any kind

  124. gary

    I’ve gotten some great chocolate bars

  125. Pilar

    The best thing I had got was the Ivory+Mason sunglasses from the FFF box

  126. Debby Stefanini

    In the popsugar box the Ikat scarf is my favorite so far.

  127. Catherine

    My first mystery box was a small women’s one before they updated the sizes. So I ordered again and got the large women’s box. I got the mint TKO watch, scarf, necklace and sunshield phone accessory set. I am so happy with it! Seems like there are lots of variations of content too.

  128. Kimberly

    Hard to pick just one! My favorite recent items is the china glaze nail polish from my fancy mystery box.

  129. Hannah R.

    The Turkish towel from psmh le box! I never thought I’ll get excited over a towel but I can’t wait for a weekend getaway. I also love how light it is! Love, love it!

  130. Heather

    I just started sub boxing a month ago but so far I’ve absolutely loved my UD 24/7 Eyeliner from this months Ipsy bag!

  131. Sam L

    PopSugar’s first luxury box candle! I am hesitant to burn it all the way down since I love the smell!

  132. Jessica

    I got the Alex & Ani bracelet in my first ever glossybox – and that was awesome!

  133. Kate

    Probably a scarf from popsugar

  134. I can’t think of any one item that I love the most, but have gotten some great items in birchbox/ipsy that I had never heard of and thought were great, one was a mascara and one was the no more pores!

  135. Amy

    I’ve been eyeing the Too Faced palette for months when Popsugar spoilers were released and was able to get the whole box for 50% (using the code on your blog!) so I’m super happy about that 🙂

  136. Janaya

    The best thing I be gotten is most of my ipsy bags! The actual bag itself. I’m a sucker for cute makeup bags so now I get a new one every month, plus they make great gifts!

  137. Jennifer Schrader

    The love the dogeared necklace we got last month in the popsugar box.

  138. Dawn

    The best thing(s) I’ve received in a sub box is hair products. I’m a bit vain about my hair so anything that makes my hair look and feel better makes me happy. I know, weird but there it is. Second would be awesome lip glosses, which I adore.

  139. Laura

    I’ve been wanting to try out Fancybox! So far I’ve been loving Stitchfix, and Wantables Intimates has been hit or miss.

  140. Tuesday C

    I think one of my favorite things I ever got in a sub box was the Juice Beauty Stem Cellular Moisturizer because that was already a fave and it was perfect timing as I had just run out! 🙂

  141. Amanda R

    I would have to say the brokedown scarf, I absolutely love it!

  142. Kaleyos

    I purchased a ModCloth Stylish Surprise (I paid $10) and ended up with aGORGEOUS red wool trench coat by Hell Bunny worth about $200.

  143. Alexia561

    Best thing I’ve ever gotten from a mystery box is a tie between the blue scarf from Popsugar and the blank journals from Fancy, as I use them both! Thanks for the giveaway. So nice of you! 🙂

  144. Misolee

    I’ve only had one box from a discontinued company and I wasn’t too impressed with the stuff in it. Getting the citrus lane box tomorrow so hopefully it will be better!

  145. Tammy

    This is hard but for value, practicality and fun the best things I got were two great coats from the ModCloth surprise boxes. I just wish it had stayed cold enough for me to wear them once before next fall.

  146. Regan

    I don’t have a subscription to any boxes. I visited the site to get an idea what these boxes are all about.

  147. Kiley Y.

    I’m new to the subscription box world, but I used to get these grab bags when I was a kid during a vacation to maine and they had THE BEST glow in the dark bugs. As a seious answer

  148. Alice

    I really liked when popsugar gave the book and movie passes.

  149. Hannah

    I’ve only been a subscription box addict for 2 months so my options are little, but I really loved the salt & vinegar cassava chips in my 1st Love With Food box (March’s box)
    I also love the Air Repair Rescue Balm from my March Birchbox & the Color Club polish in this months box!

  150. megan

    I never buy nail polish for myself so I always appreciate getting them in boxes. This week I got the gold one from Birchbox. Even though I really wanted the mint one it’s something new in my line up of mostly reds and purples.

  151. Jorja

    It’s way too hard for me to pick one favorite! I love the Beauty Detector leave-in conditioner and detangler I got from birchbox though. I’ve re-ordered three times since I received the sample!

  152. Kelly

    I only get Julep and a mystery bag from an indie nail polish company. So my best thing would have to be…nailpolish 🙂

  153. Amy S.

    Anything that was expensive, lol!

  154. shannon

    Its hard to say, but I always love all the items in barkbox and I love to get primer

  155. Lori

    The foaming face mask from January’s Popsugar.

  156. Joanne

    I got really lucky with a really pretty dress from the modcloth grab bags.

  157. allison

    Favorite thing: itCosmetics blush brush from New Beauty test tube

  158. Jennifer

    I love nearly allll of my Golden Tote items!!

  159. Meredith Morris

    I just received (FINALLY!) my large mystery box from Fancy and I am super pumped about it! They sent the blue Milano Skeleton TKO ORLOGI watch. I absolutely love it!

    1. Jennifer

      Ohh, I love that watch! Great box!

  160. Jean Eckert

    My best discovery from a subscription box was learning about Green Toys! I had never heard of this brand before Citrus Lane and now my kiddos have it all 🙂

  161. Tonya K.

    Best thing I ever got?

    hm… probably the Surface Trinity Protein Spray from FabFitFun!

    1. Tonya K.

      and glad you are back! I think I tried to load like 10 times yesterday – LOL!

      1. Jennifer

        Ahhh, it was such a mess! So many sites were down and mine was one of them!

  162. Jackie

    Such a hard question!! Either turband from FFF or a puella dress I got from a golden tote… So many good choices though!

  163. Iris

    The best… hmmm that’s a hard one, haha. But I guess for me, the best thing (in terms of utility) I’ve received is probably the Beauty Protector Protect and Oil sample from Birchbox because it’s seriously improved my hair and something I’ve now incorporated into my routine! 🙂

  164. Ashley

    Juice beauty stem cellular moisturizer…love it, wish it was cheaper!

  165. Ricki

    Out of a mystery box? I always try to grab Pick Your Plum’s grab boxes, and I have gotten a few long sleeve shirts great for layering that way. From a sample box? The pink & black Betsey Johnson tank and shorts pj set from my February Wantable Intimates box.

    1. Jennifer

      Or a subscription box or anything!

  166. Stephanie

    I have only ever gotten three boxes total so I don’t have a lot to choose from but my favorite was an orange date bar in a Love with food box.

  167. Theresa H

    The best item I’ve ever gotten in a box is my bcbgmaxazria bon genre perfume. It is from the january glossybox I believe? LOVE! It’s almost half empty.

  168. Dara

    First Aid Ultra Repair Cream from Allure. It’s the only lotion my son will let me out on him! It was a lifesaver this winter!

  169. Kathy S

    I think a liquid eyeliner from birchbox, it was the best I’ve ever used and I love liner as much as you love nail polish!

  170. Niki T.

    Hmmmm, hard question! First thing that pops into my mind is Malin+Goetz Detox Mask (fell so in love with it!) but myself favorite things to receive are makeup and books.

  171. Shannon

    My fave item I have ever gotten was the Malin and Goetz detox face wash from Pop Sugar. My skins feels so smooth for a week after I use it- even the husband noticed!

  172. April

    Looks like a super fun box, I’ve not got one of theirs before.

  173. DanitaR

    I absolutely love your page!

  174. Adrienne A

    Wow- it’s so hard to pick just one. Maybe the dogeared necklace. I put it on a gold chain and wear it on days when I need extra luck.

  175. emilia

    I loved the gem eyeliner in the ipsy bag from starlooks.

  176. Rebecca F.

    My favorite thing in a grab bag was from the Modcloth mystery items. I got a really, really amazing $150 coat for $10!

  177. Autumn

    I have never splurged on a muster box for myself, I have gotten Bluum boxes in the pas, but kept getting the same types of items every month. I did get a snuggly that my son sleeps with every night, so I guess I did get something good!!

  178. Gail

    Cult Gaia Headband was so cute.

  179. Tiffany

    Highlighter pencils and CC cream <3 …. Juicy beauty……popsugar summer box sunglasses!!!! I still love them and lost them 5m ago

  180. Debra

    The scarf from March’s PopSugar Must Have box!

  181. Annie

    So many items to choose from, my most used fav is the brokedown scarf from PopSugar!!

  182. Nicole R.

    My favorite items are the bracelets in the Popsugar Resort Box.

  183. Nicole

    I had kinda a bum small fancy box. But my favorite box I ever got has to be a klutchclub box I recently got. Or maybe the mod cloth boxes.

  184. Eve

    Cheese

  185. Jen

    The best thing I ever got in a subscription box was nail polish!! There’s nothing I (or my three girls) love better than free nail polish!!

  186. Julie Ramler

    I’m new to subscription boxes so I haven’t received anything I’ve absolutely loved yet. My daughter however is in love with the cases she gets from Phone Case of the Month.

  187. Christine

    I would have to say the books that come every month with my son’s Surprise Ride boxes. They are perfect for him to read by himself and they always go along very well with the theme of the box.

  188. Caitlin

    Such a hard question! But the best recent thing is probably the alex and ani bracelet from glossybox because it was free!

  189. katrina

    I have recieved some face lotions, serums, scrubs that i loved!

  190. Melissa M

    My favorite of all time was the black big floppy hat from last Mays (?) Popsugar box. I wear it with a black maxi and huge sunglasses and it makes me feel like a celeb lolol. Second would be Klorane Dry Shampoo from BB…seriously Im addicted, I buy a bottle before the next one is out for fear of running out during the shipping process

  191. Sarah

    I’d have to say the best thing I’ve gotten was the Buxom mascara that PopSugar sent last year (April I think?)… I LOVE this mascara and haven’t been able to go back to using anything else.

  192. Rebecca

    This sounds dumb, but in one of the Love with Food boxes I got olives. They were in aluminum type packaging and it was lovely.

  193. Des

    Not recently, but I remember as a kid I loved whenever goodie bags had those super high bouncy balls. Or those little things where it looks like a diaphragm, but you turn it inside out and lay it on a tabletop or floor and it suddenly pops up when it turns right side in again. Apparently I just like things that pop and bounce.

  194. karen

    Small, dainty, bling frames!

  195. Wehaf

    I got some handmade soap in a recent box – I LOVE handmade soap!

  196. Amanda

    The best thing I got from a grab bag was a great tee from Anthropologie in my Golden Tote!

  197. Stacie

    I just got a new running belt in my Stridebox this month. Hands down probably the best thing I’ve ever gotten.

  198. Kristin

    It may sound silly, but the elephant ring holder in the PopSugar box is one of my favorite things from a box. I had been eyeing them for months on Bauble Bar but never bought one. I couldn’t decide which one I wanted. PopSugar decided for me and my husband and I both use it every day.

  199. Elizabeth

    I tend to be a huge fan of Julep mystery boxes!

  200. Mallory B

    I ordered a Fancy mystery box back before they changed to different sizes and I got the gorgeous black clutch! Love it.

  201. Margaret

    This goes way back to childhood but the best thing I ever got in a grab bag was a sand art game. It was amazing and by far the most coveted prize at my Dad’s company picnic!

  202. Nicole Whelan

    The best item I ever got in a subscription box was a Birchbox item: Liz Earle hot cloth cleanser – I’ve never felt more pampered! It left my skin soooo soft, I couldn’t believe I got such a luxury item in my box – if it was the only thing in there I would have been happy!

  203. Kate

    I’m pretty new to the whole subscription box scene so I don’t know that I have ever got anything really all that great, to be honest! I did score a Woot! pets Bag of Crap though… oh, and of course! Grab bag t-shirts! I’m a sucker for those. My favorite from a grab bag has angry looking fruits and vegetables with the text reading ‘Eat more meat!’

  204. Theresa

    I’m STILL in love with the chevron throw from the NM popsugar box

  205. Kathy

    My favorite are the signed first editions from Powell’s.

  206. Ali M

    I haven’t gotten a ton of great things yet from boxes imo, but I’ll also go with Modcloth – my two clothing items were a bust, but I got a really cute pair of boots that are totally comfortable.

  207. Laura

    Either the first brokedown scarf in popsugar or the Clark’s botanicals marine cream in birchbox.

  208. Kam

    Oh gosh. Too many things. I love the BaB quad in Bora Bora from Ipsy. Also the Chella Highlighter.

    Popsugar wise, many jewelry items. The Dec bracelet was right up my alley. The scarf from April.

    I’ve also tried Glossy and Yuzen, loved them both but couldn’t justify the cost. Glossy was a groupon sub and I would do it again for the price.

  209. Debbie Richardson

    I’ve only ordered three mystery boxes. One from Julep – very disappointed when it ended up being more body oil and things of the like and less nail polish. And two from Fancy – the Men’s and Women’s – both of which I found to be nice, but not thrilling. I would say I have two favorite things from subscription boxes – both from Julep. The glitter polish removing kit, and the plie wand that I’m already anticipating in next months box.

  210. Diana B

    I’ve only gotten kids and food subscription boxes. The best item is probably a little blanket/stuffed animal lovey from a Bluum box.

  211. Mary

    I have never gotten a mystery box or grab bag, but get lots of sub boxes. Have gotten lots of things that I really like, and have ending buying many products that I got in a box. But, nothing really *wow* yet….Thanks for the giveaway!

  212. Nancy

    I haven’t gotten a subscription box yet. I keep reading your reviews to see which one I should get! I’m on a wait-list for ipsy. 🙁

  213. Ruby Yoshi

    I like the diffuser from pop sugar

  214. Laura

    Oh this is hard… Maybe the tokyomilk….

  215. deanna

    I got a box of cool socks once. I love socks.

  216. Monica

    My fave thing is the bags we get from ipsy… if I don’t love a bag it goes to the teens at our abuse shelter… so I feel like I have to love it… to keep it… but it makes me smile to send them a gift at Christmas that I hope they will like…

  217. nicole p

    The blue and gold bracelets from the popsugar resort box!

  218. susie king

    The best thing I got in a grab bag was hair bands.

  219. Rosa

    I think my fav thing from sub boxes so far is the kai fragrance oil (I got it in popsugar last year, but I signed up for fab fit fun so I could get another one, lol!) It smells so nice. I love florals.

    But honestly, I mostly like food boxes.

  220. Lisa Minix

    I just recently got Big Sexy Hair Root Pump spray. I use a lot of their products. Ut I had never heard of this produt but when I received it in my ipsy bag & used it I totally fell in love! The other product that I know that I will love is coming in my May Julep box. The Pile Wand!!! I can’t wait! The

  221. susana

    Recently I bought the glossybox, and it was awesome!!!! The best thing i received was a eye liner that literally looks like a marker and its so easy to put on, i love it!!!!

  222. Emily F

    I have never had a subscription box before, but I have been looking at your blog posts to see which ones I would like. I am considering getting the Conscious Box because I saw a living social deal on it. I would love to try a subscription box soon.

  223. Mandy Hensley

    I think the best thing I’ve ever received would be a gorgeous bracelet from alex & ani, what made it my favorite was that my mom hinted around several times over several months so I knew how much she liked it I decided to skip my subscription box and order it for her, well I should have guessed with my luck, they were totally sold out and making matters worse customer service wasn’t even certain rather or not it would even be back in stock. Amazingly I couldn’t believe my good luck for once in my life, I actually received the exact bracelet in my box a few weeks later. I’m still in shock, lol. AND not to mention how much it made mom happy.

  224. E Kay

    I’ve never used one

  225. Chloe

    Urban decay eyeliner.

  226. Kelsea Beth

    ModCloth Stylish Surprise I have done the clothing one a few times and a shoe, and have gotten a $90 dress that I loved and it fit perfect for $10!!!

  227. Kate K

    I’ve just signed up for two subscription boxes for the first time so I haven’t gotten anything yet. I’m excited for May though!

  228. Rebecca Brewer

    I’ve never gotten one, I just can’t justify it in the budget.

  229. Diane F

    I have never gotten a subscription box. I want to try one someday soon!

  230. joan

    I’ve only had one subscription box before. It was a Mercobox (shop local type of thing). There were some yummy protein powder and bar samples. Guess I need to get with it on subscription boxes!!

  231. Anna Bea

    I’ve not done too many subscription boxes, but I did once get a box gifted to me from an acquaintance after having a baby. It was a Glossy Box, and it was the most fabulous mail ever- I had no idea it was coming!

  232. Ricky

    My wife gets hair products that she makes me try. Some are pretty good.

  233. Krysta

    I LOVED the scarf in March’s PopSugar box, but this month’s box was also amazing. It’s such a hard choice!

  234. Beth

    I absolutely love the Nest Birchwood Pine candle from the Neiman Marcus Popsugar Box. It may be the only thing from any sub box that I use (completely) and re-buy

  235. soon perez

    I say the best things I get are the ones from kids boxes I could give to my sons like snacks and toys!

  236. Rebecca E.

    It hasn’t arrived yet, but the best thing I’ve gotten from a subscription box was the Too Faced palette from Pop Sugar.

  237. Sarah Slatter

    Hmmm…we got a puzzle from Citrus Lane that is still a favorite of my sons!

  238. Karen

    Such a difficult question! I’ll have to go with the swell bottle from the summer popsugar box since I use it the most.

  239. Ally

    Without a doubt, I have gotten some amazing pieces in my JewelMint Mytery Boxes!

  240. Sonia

    It’ been so long, I c an’t remember. i like candy and nearly all of the grab boxes/bags that I have received have had candy in them.

Leave a Reply