October 2014 PopSugar Must Have Box ~ FULL SPOILERS!!!

Disclosure: If you make a purchase through the links posted below, I may receive a small compensation. Read the full disclosure.
October 2014 PopSugar Must Have Box Spoilers!
October 2014 PopSugar Must Have Box Spoilers!

Thanks to YouTuber Lyss Ryann, we have full spoilers for the October 2014 PopSugar Must Have Box! Here they are:

~K. Hall Designs Soap (Shea Butter / Olive Oil) ($10)
~Mine Chalkboard Soy Message Ceramic Candle ($24)
~Dean & Deluca Pumpkin Spice Maltballs ($5.50)
~Happy Socks (prints may vary) ($12)
~Butter London Wink Eye Pencil Crayon (colors may vary) ($18)
~Nailed Kit Halloween Nail Art ($8)
~Isaac Jacobs Photo Frame (~$30)

All totaled, I came up with an estimated value of $107.50 for the October 2014 PopSugar Must Have Box! If you still haven’t subscribed, click here and use the coupon code “REFER5” to save $5 off your first box or “OCT14SELECT” to save $10 off a 3-month subscription!  What do you think so far?

Screen Shot 2014-01-11 at 10.35.35 PM

Spread the love


Jennifer is the author and founder of Subscription Box Ramblings. She first discovered subscription boxes in 2012 and has been addicted since. Current favorites include CAUSEBOX, Boxycharm and Beachly!

This Post Has 53 Comments

  1. Lana

    I really love everything in the box. I think the theming is on point, and it reminds me of what I used to love about the original pop sugar boxes (wide variety of items, not ONE big ticket item – so if you don’t like that, the box really isn’t worth anything).

    1. Jennifer

      I total agree. It’s like some of their older boxes!

  2. Patricia

    Ooooh everything looks great! Can never have too many candles or pictures frames (I actually already own both of the ones in this box and loooove them). The frame is one of my favorites you can put a picture on each side.I don’t usually do nail decals but these are too cute for halloween I can’t wait to see those little jack o’lantern faces on my fingers 🙂 This box is doesn’t seem to have one big ticket item but everything in this box will definitely be used or make fun gifts 🙂

    1. Jennifer

      It reminds me of some of their earlier boxes that didn’t have one big item!

  3. Madelyn


    1. Dany

      Same, not impressed at all. I’ve tried to cancel my subscription but customer service seems to be overwhelmed and the site has no record of my subscription.

    1. Jennifer

      HA! It looked closest to the one in the video!

  4. Mary

    The only thing I want are those pumpkin spice malt balls. I think I might go order those instead of the box!

  5. Kristin

    I had to cancel my subscription (getting a new car condition from the hubs) but the only thing I want is the candle and I think it’s just because I Love choc-board paint right now

    1. Amy

      I’ll send you my candle. I hate candles. (The whole box looks ks pretty awful to me, actually. Oh well.) Email me at amylrox at aol dot com. I’m happy to send the candle your way.

  6. kirsten

    I’m digging everything but the soap!

  7. PA Anna

    It’s OK. I will be gifting most of the items.

  8. Emmie

    Ugh, this box sucks IMO. I don’t want any of it. So sad I wasted my rue lala code on it. This will be my first and last popsugar box. 🙁

    1. Amy

      I agree. I can’t believe they would send a whole box of crap. The eyeliner will probably be orange.

      1. Lana

        The person in the video got a grey eyeliner, which looked pretty, if that helps at all?

  9. Ashley

    Thanks for sharing!

    Not a fan :(. I might be cancelling, this will be my 3rd box. I liked my first box, second was okay, I think I will try one more month.

    1. Jennifer

      I say give it another month!

  10. Debbie

    I don’t really like anything in the box, so I canceled my account for this month, I ordered boxycharm and maybe I will pick one more other box.

    1. Jennifer

      I LOVE Boxycharm!!!!!

  11. Becky

    This box looks great to me! I will make use of everything and that makes it a win for me.

  12. PA Anna

    I went to cancel the box and already had been billed. It never occurred to me that I would had been billed earlier in the month with all the problems people have been experiencing. Somehow, despite all their problems, they were able to bill me on Oct 1st when I gifted myself the sub. I’m holding off on November’s box until I see the spoilers.

    1. Jennifer

      I should figure out if I have been billed yet. Better yet, I should ask my SIL if she got the Sept. box I ordered her..

    2. Sara

      Are you sure you have been charged? My popsugar account shows that I was charged for my box on Oct. 3, but as of today I still have not had a credit card charge for it. And, it seems from the blogs as if many have had that experience.

      1. PA Anna

        Yes, I checked my credit card account because I wanted to cancel based on the spoilers. I gifted myself which billed it right away to the credit card. Bummer because the items don’t interest me. I can gift them, but I could had taken that 40 and bought more personalized gifts for people. I am going to use the Halloween nail art if it shows up. It’s doubtful that it will show up on time, because I am always in the second or third wave. Funny thing is my sister and I both receive our boxes at the same time even though she is subscriber and I gift myself.

        1. PA Anna

          I’m not feeling warm and fuzzy feelings towards the company. I did not like the LE box and now this box. That’s a $140.00 I wasted. I know it is a gamble, but I think I would had like the PopSugar boxes of the past better.

  13. Dani

    Wow what happened this month? I am not excited at all to get this =(

  14. thenewgirl

    I’m glad I cancelled, it’s like a box of jinks u get out of a rummage sale.

  15. Jen Leonard

    The only loss for me is the malt balls. I LOVE Dean & Deluca, but am allergic to cinnamon darn it. Maybe they’ll send different flavors? If the eye pencil is a crazy color (not black or brown) one of my daughters will love it and one of my girls loves cinnamon, so this box is another winner for me. Keep this streak going PopSugar!!

    1. Jennifer

      Your daughters are lucking out this month too!

  16. Debra

    I am digging everything but the nail art but I think I might do my toes. What ever I can’t use or like goes to the other women in my family so we always have fun with it. Sharing is good if there si something in particular that doesn’t fancy you. I have a guest room that whoevre happens to visit gets a little gift (mainly my daughter). A littel surprise here and there..we LOVE Popsugar!

    1. Jennifer

      I bet people love coming over!

  17. Debra

    oops, didn’t spell check! Egg on face 🙁

  18. Hilda

    What a fun surprise to wake up to this morning. I’m really excited about this box. I will always love candles and frames. The socks look really cute and comfy. I haven’t used a bar soap in a very long time so it’ll be fun to try. The nail art is not something I’d buy myself so it’s a fun treat to play with this month. Anything Dean & Deluca will be fun to taste test. The only miss for me is the eyeliner because you know how I feel about eyeliners. LOL. Can’t wait to get my box!!!

    1. Jennifer

      I too always love candles and frames!

  19. Maria A.

    I like it. I think is a practical box. I know I will use everything one way or another. Very fallish theme imo, which is good for Oct. Overall happy with it. Can’t wait! 🙂

    1. Jennifer

      Did you watch the video? Those malt balls look giant. They have me so curious.

      1. Maria A.

        Yes I did and YES they do, can’t wait to try them! LOL 🙂

  20. Kathy

    Thanks for the spoilers so I’m not stuck with this box. The candle & candy look good, but bar soap – ewww, and the rest is kinda meh. Last month was great, so really hoping that November will be another winner.

    1. Jennifer

      I don’t think you can ever go wrong with a candle!

  21. Mo

    This is all okay stuff, not nearly as great as the September box. With all the Halloween stuff, they better ship soon. The brownie in my September box was already expired by the time I got the box.

    1. Jennifer

      They totally need to! My box takes at least a week and I know some people’s take over 10 days!

  22. Jenny

    This box sucks… I’m so disappointed 🙁

  23. Peggy

    I’ve been really excited over all of the comments on these
    monthly boxes, but I am so disappointed with this month!
    The only things that I’d love are the soap, candles and socks.
    I will be anxious to see what November has to offer!
    Again, ladies, I love all of your comments!

  24. Kate

    I don’t do Pop Sugar anymore but I think this is a nice box. What you can’t use, you can re-gift. I hate when they send the big ticket items that are very specific. This month’s box has me thinking I might re-subscribe before the holidays.

  25. Lavinia Gass

    I ordered September and cancelled for October. I had a feeling the October box would be so-so. I’m debating on resubscribing for November. I wish Popsugar gave you the option of skipping a month.

  26. Amanda

    Did anyone’s subscription get cancelled w the new platform?! Mine did.

    1. Nicole

      I just realized mine got cancelled too!!! What the heck?!?!?!

  27. Wendi

    Not too excited about this box. I signed up because I missed out on a great box. I thought the August box amazing with Bite lip gloss and Kendra Scott jewelry. Last months was Okay. I feel it was worth the money. I would pay $30 for a great scarf and $10 for some ear buds. I did not need chocolate and pencils. I am going to give it one more month and if I am not impressed I might cancel.

  28. Susan

    I just got my box today, and am happy with everything in it. It’s not the highest value box I’ve received from them, but I’ll use all the items. I got a red/gray cheetah print for the socks, which I like better than the yellow ones in the picture. Also I got gray eyeliner instead of blue.

    1. Jennifer

      I hope mine comes soon! I am excited for that candle!

  29. Courtney

    I’ve been a member since September 2012. I have to say? This box is probably bottom 3 for me.

Leave a Reply