POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box Review #1 – July 2016

Disclosure: If you make a purchase through the links posted below, I may receive a small compensation. Read the full disclosure.
POPSUGAR Must Have Box
Cost: Full-Size: $39.95/month. Must Have Mini: $18.95/month. All-Star Mystery Box: $19.95 (one-time purchase). Now sold out.
Ships To: United States
Coupon Code: Use coupon code “MUSTHAVE5” to save $5 off your first full-size PopSugar Must Have Box.

POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box Review #1

POPSUGAR Must Have Box is an exciting box full of fun, must-have picks across fashion, beauty, home decor, fitness, and more, which is delivered to your door on a monthly basis. Boxes include full-size products and premium items including tried-and-true classics, celebrity favorites, and brands consumers have yet to discover worth over $100!

This review is on their now sold-out All-Star Mystery Box. The box was $19.95 and promised to include six products worth over $100+ from past must have boxes.

POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box Review #1

POPSUGAR Must Have Box ships via FedEx Smart Post. This box shipped out of NY, but I also have one coming to me from CA, so I think they were just randomly shipped from their facilities.

POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box Review #1

I believe there was a total of 8 or 9 difference POPSUGAR All-Star Mystery Box variations. Here is what I received in mine:

~K. Hall Simpatico Ambergris Shea Butter Cream ($22): This hand cream is rich and alone makes the price of the box worth it to me. From the November 2014 Box.

POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box Review #1
~Terrapin Ridge Farms Pecan Honey Mustard ($6.15):  Meh.  I wasn’t excited to get this in my box. Some people claim this is the best mustard ever, but I don’t like any mustard, so this will end up being passed along, or B will take it to his work. From the November 2015 Box

POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box Review #1
~Tarte Cosmetics Beauty & The Box Amazonian Clay Eye Shadow Quad (Apple of My Eye) ($22): Super pretty colors!  I still have some left in my original quad, but I certainly don’t mind another one. From the November 2015 Box.

POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box Review #1
~Wine Glass Writer 3-Pack For POPSUGAR Must Have ($9.95): I just found my original ones when we were cleaning out the kitchen drawers and have been using them to doodle on my Member’s Mark Yeti knock-off cups.  Although I wish the colors were different, I am happy to get a second set.  From the November 2014 Box.

POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box Review #1
~Deepa Gurnani Katie Crystal Headband ($56): I was reading some spoilers on this box, and it didn’t seem like a lot of people were excited to get this.  And looking back at my November review, I wasn’t really either.  I was even toying with the idea of wearing it as a bracelet.  Nope.  I wear this as a headband all.the.time. It’s probably one of my all-time favorite POPSUGAR box items.  If I have my hair back in a bun or ponytail and then put this on, I’m automatically more “dressed-up”. LOVE! From the November 2015 Box.

POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box Review #1

POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box Review #1
~Capri Blue Mercury Jewel Box in Rain (4oz) ($18.95): I loved this candle so much when I first got it that I snagged the one my SIL didn’t want too.  I am super excited to get another.  They are gorgeous, and they smell fabulous. From the November 2015 Box

POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box Review #1

All totaled my POPSUGAR All-Star Mystery Box had a value of $135.05.  Since I have been subscribing to POPSUGAR since the beginning, I knew everything I’d receive was a repeat, but I was quite pleased with the repeats I received.  With the exception of the mustard, I will use every single item in here myself.  What a great value for the price too!

As I mentioned the POPSUGAR All-Star Mystery Box is now sold out, but new subscribers can use coupon code “MUSTHAVE5” to save $5 off their first full-sized POPSUGAR must Have Box!

Spread the love


Jennifer is the author and founder of Subscription Box Ramblings. She first discovered subscription boxes in 2012 and has been addicted since. Current favorites include CAUSEBOX, Boxycharm and Beachly!

This Post Has 5 Comments

  1. Margaret

    Your box was a little different than mine. I ended up getting four ergonomic wine glasses, the mustard, the headband (which I didn’t like at first but love), bubble bath and some great note cards. It was a fun box !

  2. Alecia

    After you burnt your candle, did you use the box for jewelry?

  3. Kathy

    I hadn’t subbed with Popsugar for over a year, half of my two boxes were items I had previously gotten in past boxes. I recieved two different boxes, one had a variation of the Tarte eyeshadow (eye candy) love the colors!. My boxes shared one item, the Studio~Hall large bar of Shea butter/olive oil soap… I’m happy about this… I’m needing some moisturizing soap these days. The only item I was “Oh well!” on was the Acme 24 paper Chevron straws. Overall very happy with my boxes.

  4. Britney

    I got mine today except I’m missing the headband. I doubled check myself before emailing them and asking if they could correct this since I only received five items instead of the promised six. Hopefully their customer service can correct it, because I really want that silly head band!

  5. Chandra

    I received everything you did except I got the Ansel book instead of the lotion. All and all I’m okay with it this will make some great gifts. I hope they do another mystery box soon.

Leave a Reply