Disclosure: If you make a purchase through the links posted below, I may receive a small compensation. Read the full disclosure.
POPSUGAR Must Have Box
Cost: Full-Size: $39.95/month. Must Have Mini: $18.95/month. All-Star Mystery Box: $19.95 (one-time purchase). Now sold out.
Ships To: United States
Coupon Code: Use coupon code “MUSTHAVE5” to save $5 off your first full-size PopSugar Must Have Box.
POPSUGAR Must Have Box is an exciting box full of fun, must-have picks across fashion, beauty, home decor, fitness, and more, which is delivered to your door on a monthly basis. Boxes include full-size products and premium items including tried-and-true classics, celebrity favorites, and brands consumers have yet to discover worth over $100!
This review is on their now sold-out All-Star Mystery Box. The box was $19.95 and promised to include six products worth over $100+ from past must have boxes.
POPSUGAR Must Have Box ships via FedEx Smart Post. This box shipped out of NY, but I also have one coming to me from CA, so I think they were just randomly shipped from their facilities.
I believe there was a total of 8 or 9 difference POPSUGAR All-Star Mystery Box variations. Here is what I received in mine:
~K. Hall Simpatico Ambergris Shea Butter Cream ($22): This hand cream is rich and alone makes the price of the box worth it to me. From the November 2014 Box.
~Terrapin Ridge Farms Pecan Honey Mustard ($6.15): Meh. I wasn’t excited to get this in my box. Some people claim this is the best mustard ever, but I don’t like any mustard, so this will end up being passed along, or B will take it to his work. From the November 2015 Box
~Tarte Cosmetics Beauty & The Box Amazonian Clay Eye Shadow Quad (Apple of My Eye) ($22): Super pretty colors! I still have some left in my original quad, but I certainly don’t mind another one. From the November 2015 Box.
~Wine Glass Writer 3-Pack For POPSUGAR Must Have ($9.95): I just found my original ones when we were cleaning out the kitchen drawers and have been using them to doodle on my Member’s Mark Yeti knock-off cups. Although I wish the colors were different, I am happy to get a second set. From the November 2014 Box.
~Deepa Gurnani Katie Crystal Headband ($56): I was reading some spoilers on this box, and it didn’t seem like a lot of people were excited to get this. And looking back at my November review, I wasn’t really either. I was even toying with the idea of wearing it as a bracelet. Nope. I wear this as a headband all.the.time. It’s probably one of my all-time favorite POPSUGAR box items. If I have my hair back in a bun or ponytail and then put this on, I’m automatically more “dressed-up”. LOVE! From the November 2015 Box.
~Capri Blue Mercury Jewel Box in Rain (4oz) ($18.95): I loved this candle so much when I first got it that I snagged the one my SIL didn’t want too. I am super excited to get another. They are gorgeous, and they smell fabulous. From the November 2015 Box
All totaled my POPSUGAR All-Star Mystery Box had a value of $135.05. Since I have been subscribing to POPSUGAR since the beginning, I knew everything I’d receive was a repeat, but I was quite pleased with the repeats I received. With the exception of the mustard, I will use every single item in here myself. What a great value for the price too!