Poll: What’s been your favorite PopSugar box to date?

Disclosure: If you make a purchase through the links posted below, I may receive a small compensation. Read the full disclosure.
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links.
PopSugar thru the years!
PopSugar thru the years!

Sorry, there are no polls available at the moment.
There’s always so much discussion about PopSugar boxes, so I though we’d do a little poll and see what everyone’s favorite (or what you think your favorite would have been since the beginning of PopSugar!  I looking back at all the boxes together, I think I enjoyed September 2012 (with the grey Brokedown scarf), December 2013 (with the Bodum mugs), June 2013 (with the scarf and Juice Beauty)!

What about you?  Which haas you’re favorite?  I can’t wait to hear the results on this one!  Oh and if you aren’t totally sure what was in each box, here are the links to my monthly reviews for the boxes: July 2012August 2012September 2012October 2012November 2012December 2012January 2013February 2013March 2013April 2013May 2013June 2013July 2013August 2013September 2013,  October 2013November 2013December 2013January 2014,February 2014

And not only what is your favorite PopSugar month, what’s your favorite item you have ever received in one?
Screen Shot 2014-01-11 at 10.35.35 PM

Spread the love


Jennifer is the author and founder of Subscription Box Ramblings. She first discovered subscription boxes in 2012 and has been addicted since. Current favorites include CAUSEBOX, Boxycharm and Beachly!

This Post Has 46 Comments

  1. kristina moya

    It’s not on the list to vote….December 2013 🙂

    1. kristina moya

      oh it is on there…LOL! On the pic it says dec 2013 but it is dec 2012!

      1. Jennifer

        All fixed now!

  2. Jennifer Frank-Lopez

    The brokedown scarf was definitely my favorite popsugar item. LOVE IT!!!

    1. Jennifer

      Love that one too!

  3. Alison

    I love my Corkatoo Corkscrew and Heather Belle Signature Tassle Necklace from March 2013!!

    1. Jennifer

      I do love that corkscrew!

  4. Lisa D

    I love the scarf from the Nov. 2013…..although I am new to the sub- I checked out all your reviews before signing up. The one that I liked was the Dec 2012 & the July 2013 ones from your reviews (but I didn’t get those boxes). However, I know I get my moneys worth- I seem to get things I would gift more then keep myself. And I sub’d for me not for others to get gifts. It was the one box a month that was suppose to be all mine. And it hasn’t been. I am paid out to April (I think) and then if I continue to get duds I will not renew. I understand they won’t have everything gear to my likings…..but I must have expected more….IDK

    1. Jennifer

      We use those mugs from December every day still!

  5. Aimee V

    I can’t vote! I loved and disliked something from every box! I’m just happy popsugar must have still arrives at my door! I’ve received this box from the start, and I’m still obsessed!

    1. Jennifer

      Ha! Same here!!!! It pretty much were my addiction started!

  6. Jennifer

    It was so hard to choose! There’s always at least one thing in each box that I use almost on a daily basis. June 2013 was my first box and I was completely sold on PopSugar after that box. I still use the Juice beauty moisturizer almost every day!

    1. Jennifer

      I had trouble picking!

  7. Jill

    I loved September 2012 which was luckily my first box. My second choice would have been May 2013. The next poll should be least favorite box!

    1. Jennifer

      LOL!!!! I should!

  8. Pilar

    I like October 2012, but I didn’t subscribe till March 2013 and it seems like all the boxes after that has been a letdown.

    1. Jennifer

      June 2013 was one of the great new too!

  9. tara m

    I picked September 2012 because I just remember opening that box and being amazed by everything in it especially the scarf! It was so hard to choose between that and June 2013 because I really loved that one also …and February 2013! I think my favorite and most used item is probably the wet brush it makes brushing mine and my daughter’s hair so much easier that I would be lost without it. I just cancelled my subscription because I am trying to save money and haven’t been wowed the last couple months, but I am already going crazy thinking about not getting it and am probably gonna have to go resubscribe!

    1. Jennifer

      Its so hard to pick!!!! I remember being SO wowed in September 2012 as well!

      1. Tara m

        Yup after looking at all the boxes again I already went and resubscribed! I couldn’t take it! Don’t tell my husband 😉

        1. Jennifer


  10. Nicole

    I didn’t get June 2013, but it does look awesome. September 2012 was my first and I was blown away!

    1. Jennifer

      Such a good one!

  11. Marietta

    The September,2012 for sure! My second favorite was June, 2013. I just wish they sent a bag each month… You know, must have BAG?? Remember? That rocked.

    1. Jennifer

      Ha! I remember! You can see the bag in my July 2012 pic!

  12. Brianna

    So this is totally off-topic, I don’t get popsugar… but I am waiting on one of those Julep Cupid Mystery boxes you’ve been posting about, and the shipping says it’s almost two pounds. I’m so curious….what’s in that box?!?! I got pedi.

    1. Jennifer

      Hmm. Maybe a full sized foot cream?

  13. Jenny

    My first box was Sept 2012 and I would say that its my favorite. Loved the scarf and the movie. It was so great. Not sure what my all time favorite thing was. It was my first hair elastics and I do love those so possible the introduction of them to my life.

    1. Jennifer

      I think this was the first place I’d seen them too!

  14. Alicia

    I voted November 2012 ONLY because I joined in Oct and didnt wanted to vote on a box I didnt get to see in person. Because I LOVED so many before I actaully subscribed!!

    1. Alicia


    2. Jennifer

      Makes sense!

  15. Bethany

    Ha, I picked June 2013 (even though I didn’t even know about PS/start subscribing until November 2013)–just based on your reviews. Looks like lots of people agree!! I haven’t been as in love with the boxes I’ve received thus far as I am with the ones that came before I subscribed.. Holding on hope they start to get amazing again!

    1. Jennifer

      We are probably due for a super amazing one soon!

  16. Wanica

    Def June 2013. Read the book, loved the Juice.

  17. Kayla

    I still can’t get over how much I love the BaubleBar Necklace from July 2013 and the scarf from June 2013. I realllllly wish I was subscribed last year because there was so much good stuff! 🙁 I am very glad to be subscribed now, though!

    1. Jennifer

      I will never not subscribe!

  18. Iris

    All this has made me realize is that I wish I had known about Popsugar/subscriptions boxes earlier/before the quality of curation started going down. XD

    1. Jennifer

      I think it’s been cyclical since the beginning!

  19. kim

    I’ve been on the fence about ordering a box. Most of the reviews I’ve seen have been on the negative side.. Glad to see some positives. Can anyone tell me how the boxes are shipped.. USPS or UPS?

    1. Jennifer

      They ship via FedEx Smart Post

  20. kim

    Also.. do they send a confirmation email when order is shipped with an estimated arrival date ? Thank You

    1. Jennifer

      They send a confirmation when it is shipped along with a tracking number.

  21. stephanie

    I signed up when I saw the scarf for this month’s box. Hoping its worth it!!!

  22. Preethi

    It’s pretty clear that the “favorite” PopSugar boxes are the ones that include nice scarves! The top 3 through the poll are the Michael Stars scarf from November 2013, the Gorjana & Griffin scarf from June 2013 and the Brokedown scarf from September 2012. I’m sure if March 2014 was included in the poll, it would be easily be in the top 4. I feel like PopSugar should somehow be told this info so that they include more scarves and keep their subscribers happy! Haha

    1. Jennifer

      Agreed. I think scarves = good boxes. I don’t know why, but that seems to be the consensus.

Leave a Reply