POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box Reveal

Disclosure: If you make a purchase through the links posted below, I may receive a small compensation. Read the full disclosure.
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links.
POPSUGAR Must Have Box
Cost: Full-Size: $39.95/month. Must Have Mini: $18.95/month. All-Star Mystery Box: $24.95 (one-time purchase). Now sold out.
Ships To: United States
Coupon Code: Use coupon code “MUSTHAVE5” to save $5 off your first full-size PopSugar Must Have Box.

POPSUGAR All-Start Mystery Box Reveal
POPSUGAR Must Have Box is an exciting box full of fun, must-have picks across fashion, beauty, home decor, fitness, and more, which is delivered to your door on a monthly basis. Boxes include full-size products and premium items including tried-and-true classics, celebrity favorites, and brands consumers have yet to discover worth over $100!

This (sort of) review is on their now sold-out All-Star Mystery Box. The box was $24.95 and promised to include six products worth over $100+ from past must have boxes.

POPSUGAR All-Start Mystery Box Reveal

Since I have received / received all these things in past POPSUGAR Must Have Box boxes; I thought I would just share the items I received, list the values and note which box they arrived in.

POPSUGAR All-Start Mystery Box Reveal

It looks like there were ten box variations and I received Box #8 (2.1lbs – shipped from NY) which included:

~Christian Lacroix Paris Paseo Sticky Note Folio ($13) – (August 2016 Box)

POPSUGAR All-Start Mystery Box Reveal

POPSUGAR All-Start Mystery Box Reveal

~Triple C Power Gloss in Silver ($30) – (August 2016 Box)

POPSUGAR All-Start Mystery Box Reveal

~Oribe Dry Texturizing Spray ($22) (TODAY Show Box – December 2015)

POPSUGAR All-Start Mystery Box Reveal

~Cargo Cosmetics “The Big Easy” Powder Blush ($26) – (August 2016 Box)

POPSUGAR All-Start Mystery Box Reveal

~Found Goods Market Candle ($23.50) (TODAY Show Box – December 2015)

POPSUGAR All-Start Mystery Box Reveal

POPSUGAR All-Start Mystery Box Reveal

~Michael Stars Porcelain Skinny Scarf In White ($30) (July 2016 Box)

POPSUGAR All-Start Mystery Box Reveal

POPSUGAR All-Start Mystery Box Reveal

~The Gluten Free Bites Dark Chocolate Coconut Bites ($4.99) (September 2016 Box)

POPSUGAR All-Start Mystery Box Reveal
All totaled my POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box had a value of $149.49.  I’m happy with the value (and overjoyed with that candle), but not overly thrilled that I received two of the same boxes.  I know they don’t guarantee you won’t receive duplicates, but it seems as though lots of people who ordered multiple boxes also experienced this.

Did you order a POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box?  If so, what did it include and what’d you think? As I mentioned, these boxes are now sold-out.

Spread the love


Jennifer is the author and founder of Subscription Box Ramblings. She first discovered subscription boxes in 2012 and has been addicted since. Current favorites include CAUSEBOX, Boxycharm and Beachly!

This Post Has 12 Comments

  1. Britney

    I’m pretty sure this is the one I’ll be getting, except my 2.1 shipped out of CA and won’t be here until tomorrow or Monday. This is probably the one I wanted the least, but it’s ok since I don’t regularly subscribe to PS.

    1. Jennifer

      The candle is REALLY nice!!!!

  2. Brandy

    I got one and it had bingo, joe chips, cheers bottle opener, Barr co fig and grapefruit bubble elixir, briogeo deep conditioning mask, gramr post card pack, triple c power gloss universal charger, and Christian lacroix Sticky notes. I’m happy with this box. I’m an on and off subscriber so the only thing I already have was the briogeo

    1. Jennifer

      I was mainly just happy I didn’t get another book!! I do love those sticky notes too!!!

  3. Callie

    I got #7. Two of them. I’m pretty happy. I wanted the wineglasses and I got two candles. The other stuff is just bonus. I can understand that some people are disappointed because it does seem like last time they purposefully sent out different boxes. However if you order 10 boxes with no guarantee that
    they’re going to be different that’s just kind of stupid! People over at MSA are acting like PopSugar is the worst company in the world. So dramatic!

  4. Dharshi

    I got #7 too. I wasn’t too excited with it because I got the wine glasses in the last mystery box. I don’t subscribe to popsugar anymore but I buy them when they show up on gilt group or living social. So I got the bingo game and postcards already ? I can’t use the textured spray. I would’ve loved the post it notes! I hope I can gift the wine glasses to someone, it has to be someone who hasn’t heard of popsugar, though ?

  5. Amy

    I ordered two and they should arrive today. I’m hoping for one of the boxes with jewelry and afraid I’ll get the box with the jewelry box and chalkboard candle because I got those in the last mystery box. Either way it’s still a good deal for 12-14 items and I will gift any duplicates I get.

  6. Margaret

    I actually like this box the best – probably because of the candle! I like the post-its too. Anyway, Popsugar must have had a really large surplus of the scarves because it looks like all but one box have them! We need to start thinking of some creative hacks for them otherwise every person in town is going to be wearing one!

  7. Margaret

    I got the same box as you, Jen! Except for the blush, I liked it!

  8. Emily N.

    people have reported contacting them and they are offering a different box if you return one of them or a bonus item. might be worth trying for some of you. i only did one this time, but my mom has reached out to them.

  9. Amber

    I got four of box #6. It seems like everyone who ordered multiple boxes got duplicates which makes it seem like they didn’t even try to send out various boxes to those that ordered multiple boxes.

    1. Jennifer

      Did you hear that you can send duplicate boxes back? Contact customer service!

Leave a Reply